The Victorian football battle for Bolton's favours

 

 

The Victorian football battle for Bolton’s favours   

The story of John Goodall – England’s Scotch Professor (1863-1942)

When the history of football first began to be written in the 1930s it was generally recognised that John Goodall (1863-1942) was the first great professional footballer. He was the icing on the cake for the Preston North End side who captured the League and FA Cup double in the first season of league football in 1888-89 when he also became the first Golden Boot by outscoring everyone else.

England international John, who scored 12 goals for his country in 14 matches during which he twice captained the side, and his Irish international brother Archie had earlier become the first brothers to play for Everton. Earlier John had moved from his Kilmarnock home to represent Great Lever, one of the first sides to defy the ban on players being paid for their efforts, between 1884 and May 1885. It was a period when Lever and their bitter local rivals Bolton Wanderers really did fight one another in the battle for supremacy in a town not big enough for two professional outfits.

On Saturday 22 December, 1993, Kilmarnock Athletic played at Great Lever, a Bolton suburb, before a 2,000 strong crowd. Howarth drew first blood for the home side but Thompson equalised with a high shot that sailed over James Trainer. After the interval, John Goodall raised hopes when he hit the crossbar. The expectation that a goal would follow could not be denied. So, when Trainer, a coach-builder signed from Wrexham, saved from Morton, Goodall latched on to the rebound to put his side ahead and before the end Gourdie made it 3-1. In a sign that team formations everywhere were aligning both teams lined up in a 2-2-6 formation, Goodall pairing at centre with Higgins.

Just over a week later the Athletic News reported that: “The Kilmarnock team were so infatuated by Bolton on their recent visit, that three of their number refused to return to the land o’ cakes and thus it was that 42 Rule Breaker In Bold Transfer South Goodall, Walkinshaw and ‘Lucas’ played in the Great Lever team on Saturday against Halliwell.” (Athletic News 02-01-1884)

Great Lever had previously lost 5-0 to Halliwell. What a difference now! With Goodall, Lucas and Walkinshaw starting, Great Lever, watched by a much improved gate of 5,000, won 3-2 thanks to a late goal from Bradbury, listed in a 2-2-6 formation as a centre alongside Goodall.

Although legally there was no such thing, Goodall, aged 20, was now a professional footballer, the first of which is believed to have been James Lang at Sheffield Wednesday in 1876. John Goodall was to remain in professional football for over three decades.

Great Lever was challenging Lancashire’s top clubs and had just moved to a new home, Woodsides, which may possibly be the earliest form of ground naming as the club’s benefactors, the Roscoe mill-owning family, had two mills that carried the same name. The new ground, close to a house named Woodlands, was on Manchester Road. By installing turnstiles, money could be taken at the gate. The opening fixture in September was against Stoke, who had been formed in 1868. 

Goodall hits five in Sunderland’s record defeat 

‘On Saturday, 23rd February, 1884, Sunderland advertised they were travelling to Lancashire to play some noted clubs from the area, such as Great Lever, Blackburn Rovers and Blackburn Olympic. However, only Great Lever, wearing red and white stripes, were played, in a match arranged by the Reverend Hindle, whose brother kept an Accrington hotel. No reports ever got back to the North East newspapers. In the North West press, Great Lever’s opposition were billed as ‘Durham’. 

‘The subterfuge was uncovered in the Athletic News by Alfred Grundy, indignant secretary of the new Durham FA, who patently did not want the FA to be associated with the match and emphatically stated that it was Sunderland AFC, the only club to be formed, in 1880, by a trade union, who were the opposition. The reason was obvious, Sunderland lost 11-0. Even when the club held their AGM at the end of the season, this significant match – Sunderland had previously travelled no more than about 30 miles for a game – was not mentioned and not included in the published playing record for the season.’

The result is that Sunderland’s record defeat has never been acknowledged as such by the Wearside club. Goodall scored five.  

On 15 March, 1884, Great Lever played 1883 FA Cup holders Blackburn Olympic, recently beaten 4-1 in the FA Cup semi-final by Queen’s Park. The home fans’ enthusiasm was apparent as they saw their side draw 1-1 in a match they would probably have won if James Trainer had not been blinded by the sun as Thomas Dewhurst’s shot sailed past him late on. Goodall had headed home in the first period.

Great Lever then easily beat Halliwell 4-1 at home. When the sides met again the scoreline was repeated and there was praise for Goodall and his former Kilmarnock Athletic team-mate Walkinshaw as they combined well to create numerous chances. 

Great Lever chose to strengthen their side for a game against Bolton which their supporters had labelled “The Battle for the Championship”. They brought in former quarryman Johnny Graham, one of the Preston half-backs, plus Blackburn Olympic right winger Tom Dewhurst. Rival fans had partisan cards pinned to their coats, saying “Play up Wanderers” and “Play up Great Lever”. The crowd paid half price entry and was huge. It included many women who, despite not being welcome when playing the game, were more than welcome to watch it. Afterwards the away side took away £97, as their part of the gate receipts. They also took away a famous victory, Dewhurst scoring the only goal just before half-time.

A player Derby would remember 

On 13 September, 1884, Goodall was in the Great Lever team when they faced newly-formed Derby County, whose side included Haydn Morley at centre back. In goal for what was the visitors’ first ever game was C L Gillett and he missed a Whittle cross after just five minutes that gave the 1,500 Woodside crowd something to cheer. By half-time it was 3-0 and playing with the wind behind them Great Lever doubled their advantage to win 6-0 with Goodall, who already must have had Derby selectors admiring his talents, scoring five according to some reports although his official total is four. 

In March, 1885, Great Lever again met Blackburn Olympic, a team created when local clubs Black Star and James Street amalgamated. Great Lever were well beaten 6-3 at Olympic’s Hole-I’-the’-Wall ground, now the sports field of St Mary’s College. There was revenge in a 3-1 home victory where Inglis scored Lever’s second before Goodall, who had earlier made good runs, made it 3-0 by beating John Southworth in the Olympic goal. Two thousand watched the proceedings. 

Bolton took on Great Lever at Pike’s Lane in the Bolton Charity Cup final on May 9, 1885. Wanderers had twice won the cup, in 1882 and 1883, but in the third year Astley Bridge were beaten 4-3 by Eagley, a village club who as early as 1877-78 had been accused in an anonymous letter to the Darwen News of importing players. As bigger clubs came on to the football scene there was to be no way that Eagley could compete. They ultimately folded in 1899. 

This was the first time Great Lever had reached the final.  In a one-sided match, won 5-1 by Wanderers, two players in the defeated side stood out – Trainer, who made many good saves, and Goodall, scorer of Lever’s goal. The ease of the victory had Wanderers followers in a 7,000 crowd convinced their club were now the undisputed local kings. John Goodall needed to move on. 

The seventh Lancashire FA AGM was held at the White Bull Hotel, Blackburn, on May 16, 1885.

Those present could report on Blackburn winning the FA Cup for a second season, taking it to three in a row for Lancashire clubs. Lancashire FA had also supplied six players for the North side that faced the South and beat them for the first time since the fixture was first played in 1880, it being used as a trial match for selection for the England side.

Ten days later the Athletic News reported that John Goodall had “figured in the Wanderers’ team in the last two matches, and it is generally accepted that he may become a permanency.” Playing at inside forward, Goodall had scored in a 4-1 win at Blackburn Rovers and was a replacement for an unwell Kenny Davenport in a 4-2 defeat of Accrington at Pike’s Lane. Trainer was also set to sign for Wanderers.  In fact, Goodall was to be snatched – kidnapped, in fact – by Preston North End and ended up as one of their stars of that legendary side from 1885 to 1889.

On Christmas Day, 1885, Great Lever’s tiny ground accommodated its highest ever gate with the Athletic News stating “close upon 12,000 – far and away greater than any previously seen on the ground . . . spectators coming from all sides of the town.” Bolton Wanderers were the visitors and with the wind and slope in their favour the away side were two up by the break. McWhirter soon reduced the arrears on the restart. A desperate Bolton rearguard, with Trainer playing against his former club, were then forced to kick out a number of dangerous shots. 

In a breakaway move, Bolton’s James Parkinson was tripped by right back McKernan, the Lever captain and a former Bolton Wanderers player, who was then charged by Steel, the Bolton outside-left, the Lever back appearing to retaliate by striking his opponent. The Athletic News reported that the crowd then “rushed upon the field. A brief parley ensued, which Powell (Wanderers captain) cut short by leading his men off the ground.” The game was subsequently abandoned. No action was taken by the Lancashire FA against either club or the players. 

Great Lever played their final (big match) on November 13, 1886, against Irish side Cliftonville Ireland’s first club, formed in 1879 and one of three clubs from Northern Ireland to have taken part in the FA Cup proper. The visitors arrived in Bolton on the morning of the FA Cup second round tie for which Lever had qualified after beating Bootle 4-2 away. 

Hopes of a good gate at Woodside had been hampered by miserable weather and the fact that at Pike’s Lane in the FA Cup on the same afternoon Bolton Wanderers were facing Third Lanark, twice Scottish FA Cup runners-up. Little more than a thousand were behind the ropes at kick-off time at the Lever match while six times as many watched Bolton Wanderers win a brilliant game 3-2 with Trainer playing superbly. 

The low income from their game hit Lever hard. The Bolton Evening News of Monday, 22 November, 1886, reported that Great Lever had two days earlier not made it to their match at Blackburn Olympic because of a ‘blunder.’ This meant spectators had their money returned to them and Lever were “threatened with a County Court action and appearances before the Football and Lancashire associations”. The Lancashire Evening Post reported on Wednesday, 24 November, 1886: “Great Lever professionals had struck, and refuse to play any more matches until the committee honour the payment agreement.”

The Lancashire Cup third-round match with Padiham in December, 1886, was then called off after the professionals at Great Lever “refused to play any further, owing to the committee refusing to pay them as per agreement.” – The Athletic

Great Lever were dissolved soon afterwards, although a junior club of the same name were, with help from Great Lever Wanderers, resuscitated in July, 1887. However, following a 7-1 hammering by Heywood Central on 13 November, 1887, the club closed for good. With the club unable to carry on, Bolton’s football civil war had come to an end and the Wanderers had won. 

A small number of hardback copies at £25 including postage remain available of England’s Scotch Professor: John Goodall 1863-1942 Contact Mark on 07392 852561 or at metcalfmc@outlook.com to arrange a purchase.

Alternatively buy the softback at £12.99 from:-  https://www.amazon.co.uk/Englands-Scotch-Professor-Goodall-1863-1942/dp/B0HGZNB8CM

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Will history repeat itself? When Manchester City were forced to sell all their players it was the local rivals who benefitted the most

“There is a feeling that Brian (Clough) did badly at Leeds; I’m not too sure of that.” - England international Stan Anderson was a good mate of Brian Clough

125th Hillsborough anniversary celebration kicks off campaign for new headstone for Ambrose Langley, the first captain of Hillsborough.