GOODALL BROTHERS WERE THE FIRST TO PLAY FOR EVERTON
GOODALL BROTHERS WERE THE FIRST TO PLAY FOR EVERTON Taken from John Goodall: England's Scotch Professor 1863 - 1942 by Mark Metcalf Set for release in September 2026. Hardback £25. Tom and Jimmy Costley are recognised as the first brothers to play for Everton. However, thanks to research in the summer of 2026 by Richie Gillham, secretary of the Everton FC Heritage Society, we now know that it is not the case. John Goodall debuted for Everton in February 1885 and his brother Archie debuted for Everton in December 1886. Tom Costley debuted for Everton in August 1886 and his brother Jimmy, scorer of the winning goal at the 1883 FA Cup Final, debuted for Everton in January 1887. On the afternoon of Wednesday February 4 th , 1885 Great Lever’s John Goodall is likely to have walked to Pikes Lane where he guested for Everton in a 7-0 defeat where he lined up in the following side:- Joliffe, Morris, Pickering, Welsh, Parry (captain), Finlay, Goodall, Whitt...